
I am so bummed that I didn't get to see the guys sing last night. I heard that I didn't miss much though. They will narrow the field a little tonight by eliminating 2 girls and 2 guys. If I had to chose the 4 based on what I have heard of them so far... I would have to go with Haley, Janell (or Lacey) and ANY of the guys except for Andrew or Casey.
Here we go: I always hate those choral sounding group songs that they make them do to open the show. They all look so uncomfortable... and it's
pre-recorded... so what's the point. AND... this song is a poor choice anyway. Please make it go away!
OK... the first round of girls:
Siobhan - safe (I thought she played it too safe Tuesday night. She can really belt it out... but she chose to go soft. I also didn't think that it was fair that the mix was so bad for her song. It sounded like the band was muted... and all we were hearing was the "bleed" in her mic. She sounded great though. She is probably my favorite female vocalist at this point in the competition.)
Haeley - safe (Really??? I thought she was outta here.)
Michelle - safe (The best performance for Tuesday night. Good voice. She carries herself like a seasoned performer too. Don't know how versatile she is... but she is could be a contender.)
Katelyn - safe (I thought she was true to the tune that she picked. Another contender.
Katie - safe (She can sing... I'm not a fan... but she can sing. That song was WAY too big for her)
Janell -
gone (She sounded so much better with her guitar Hollywood week. WOW... what happened??? I guess she just couldn't pull it off with the LIVE band. I knew that she would be going home tonight though. It was pretty bad Tuesday night.)
Allison Iraheta is singing tonight. Cool! She was my pick for last season. I still think that she would have been a better choice (long-term) than Kris Allen. I love her voice. I love the raspy-
ness. She sound a little more raspy than normal tonight. I wonder if she is sick? I hated the tune... but I am still a fan of that voice.
Paige - safe (She was a little "
screamy" on Tuesday night... but she can sing.)
Lacey - safe (She had a bad night Tuesday... her pitch was all over he place. I thought she might get eliminated tonight.)
Lilly - safe (She still has the quirky/unique vote from America... but that will get old after another couple of weeks.)
Crystal - safe (Again... I'm not a fan... but she CAN sing. What was up with the harmonica? That was horrible. I have heard a two-year-old spit in a harmonica and it sounded better.)
Didi - safe (Another quirky voice. That is popular so far this season. Again... I think it will get old. Especially when she has to stretch to do a genre that is out of her range.)
Ashley -
gone (I think she got voted off because she was just trying to hard. She was over-singing and her pitch was all over the place on Tuesday night. She also picked a ridiculous tune to sing. ONLY Leona can sing that one.)
The guys: (Didn't get to hear any of them sing last night.)
Michael - safe
John - safe
Aaron - safe
Todrick - safe
Tim - safe
Joe -
gone (I don't remember much about him.)
Kris Allen sings next. I have to admit... I am not a big Kris Allen fan. I like him as a person... but not feeling him as an artist. He's just OK.
Casey - safe (Great!)
Jermaine - safe
Lee - safe
Andrew - safe (YES!... all the way, baby!)
Tyler - gone (Good)
Alex - safe
Well... there you have it. You know... I have heard people say "This is the best season ever!"... or "Best talent ever on American Idol."... but I have to strongly disagree. I sure hope they bring their "A" games pretty soon. So far... Andrew is the only one with "the goods" to go the distance. I am afraid I'm losing interest in the show already. AND Ellen... is a total waste. She brings absolutely nothing to the judging of American Idol. I don't even think she is all that funny yet. Maybe at some point she will bring HER "A" game. Come on, Ellen... at least be funny!
Oh well... until next week....