
It was such an amazing evening... that we stayed outside and played as long as we possibly could. We took
Miley for a walk... and she had an absolute blast out there. I really think that we wore her out though. By the time we finished our walk... Miley was ready to get back to house and take a nap. Of course we had to get back in time for American Idol anyway.
So... here's my take on the show tonight. Again... I am going to blog while I listen to each of them sing. Here it goes:
Michael: I turned the TV on just as Michael was singing the last note of his song. The crowd absolutely LOVED him! It must have been a pretty solid performance. Uh oh... evidently Randy didn't care for the song selection. Simon likes Michael but didn't like the selection either. Wow... I guess I'll have to hear this one tomorrow on
Youtube.
Syesha: She sounds great on this song! She just left her mic stand to go to the front of the stage. She must be getting ready to really "bring it". OK... she just hit a high Eb... and ouch... it wasn't great! She's no
Mariah... or Fantasia. Not a bad performance overall... but not really memorable either. She has a nice voice.
Jason: A
ukulele?
Oh boy... we can get ready for a Simon "Tiny Tim" reference... right? You know that
somebody's gonna go there. Overall... pretty good performance... of a quirky sort of arrangement of "Somewhere Over The Rainbow". WOW... he got raving reviews from the judges. I guess I just didn't connect with the whole
ukulele thing. I still like this guy though. He is definitely unique.
Kristy Lee: I really think that this should be her week to go home. She is just not up to par with the other vocalists. Even with all of the
reverb on her vocals... she is sounds off on the lower notes of the verses. Over all: It was probably one of her better performances though. Great song choice for her "country" pipes. I still think that she should go home this week.
David Cook: Is it just me... or are the
BGVs burying the vocalists in the mix? I really want to hear David... but I'm struggling to pull him out of the mix. It may be because the song is too low for him. I'm really not into this song at all. It has such a wide range and he is just not nailing it down. I have to agree with Randy and Simon. I think that the song selection really hurt him tonight.
Carly: Man, can she ever sing?!? Strong pipes. She seems angry though.
Ooops... now she is off pitch! WOW... she almost wiped out! I still like her voice though. I just think that she needs to sing from somewhere other than "
emo" world. Hey... Simon said the same thing about the "angry" performance thing. Cool! I still like Carly a lot. I don't agree that she could be in trouble with that performance.
David Archuleta: He sounds great so far. He really should leave the piano on this chorus. Come on... come on... nope... he's still there. Oh well... it is still probably the best that I have heard him sing. I think that he needed a strong performance tonight. Great song... strong performance! OK... so maybe I'm a fan again.
Brooke: The girl can sing. Great job with a classic song. Nothing extraordinary... but very nice performance. She already reminds me a lot of Carole King... so it wasn't a real stretch.
Tonight...
(I can't believe I'm saying this) I guess I'll go with David
Archuleta... but only because I didn't get to hear my man, Michael Johns sing. And... I think that Kristy Lee or Brooke could be going home this week.
We'll see.